What It Means
Cry it out is a sleep trainingSleep trainingTeaching a baby to fall asleep on their own, both at bedtime and after waking in the night, using a planned, consistent method. See more method in which a baby is put to bed awake and left to fall asleep without being comforted during the night. Sleep specialists call it extinction, or unmodified extinction, and Cleveland Clinic describes it as the approach that asks caregivers not to comfort the child at all overnight. The Ferber methodFerber methodA sleep training method, also called graduated extinction, where parents check on a crying baby at timed intervals that lengthen over time. See more is a softer version with timed check-ins, known as graduated extinction.
Try It: Cry It Out or Ferber? Three Quick Calls
Three quick calls, answered from Cleveland Clinic and HealthyChildren.org.
1. You check on your crying baby every few minutes, a little longer each time.
Right. Timed check-ins that lengthen are graduated extinction, the Ferber method.
Not quite. Cry it out has no check-ins at all.
2. Your 2-week-old cries after a feed. Is it time for cry it out?
Right. Cleveland Clinic says newborns shouldn't be sleep trained.
Not quite. Newborns still need night feeds and can't soothe themselves yet.
3. During cry it out, your baby seems sick. Do you go in?
Right. HealthyChildren.org says to attend to a sick baby, a feed or a dirty diaper.
Go in. HealthyChildren.org says a sick baby still gets comfort.
Right so far
How Parents Say It
- "We just let him cry it out."
- "Night two of CIO and she was asleep in ten minutes."
- "I couldn't do cry it out, so we tried Ferber."
The Breakdown
By age
| Age | What the sources say | Source |
|---|---|---|
| NewbornNewbornA baby in the first 28 days of life, the stage doctors also call the neonatal period. See more | Shouldn't be sleep trained; short sleep cycles, night feeds still needed | Cleveland Clinic |
| About 4 months | Often ready to learn to settle; some earlier, some nearer 6 months | Cleveland Clinic |
| About 6 months | Brief night waking is normal, and babies need a chance to resettle | HealthyChildren.org |
How it runs
- Do the bedtime routineBedtime routineThe same short series of calm steps a child goes through each night before sleep, such as brushing teeth, reading a book and lights out at a set time. See more and lay your baby down drowsy but awakeDrowsy but awakeLaying a baby down in the crib when they're sleepy but still awake, so they practice falling asleep on their own. See more.
- Say goodnight and leave the room.
- Don't go back in to comfort, except for a feed, a dirty diaper or a baby who is sick.
- Keep the same bedtime and routine every night.
When to talk to the doctor. Ask your pediatrician before you start if you're unsure your baby is ready or no longer needs night feeds, and call if the crying sounds different from usual or your baby seems unwell.
Good to Know
HealthyChildren.org, the AAP's site for parents, says many babies can't fall asleep without some crying and settle sooner if left to cry, and that the crying shouldn't last long if the baby is truly tired. The American Academy of Sleep Medicine calls graduated extinction, the Ferber version with check-ins, an effective and recommended treatment for bedtime problems and night wakings. A 2016 trial in Pediatrics found graduated extinction caused no adverse stress responses or long-term effects on attachment. Whatever the method, keep the AAP's safe sleepSafe sleepThe AAP's rules for lowering the risk of SIDS and suffocation: baby on the back, alone, on a firm flat surface in their own sleep space, every sleep. See more rules: on the back, alone, on a firm, flat surface with only a fitted sheet.
FAQ
What is the cry it out method?
You put your baby to bed awake and don't go back in to comfort them overnight, so they learn to fall asleep alone. It's also called extinction.
What age can you start cry it out?
Cleveland Clinic says babies are often ready for sleep training around 4 months, with some a bit earlier and some closer to 6 months, and that newborns shouldn't be sleep trained. Check with your pediatrician first.
Is cry it out the same as the Ferber method?
No. Cry it out has no check-ins. The Ferber method, or graduated extinction, adds brief check-ins at intervals that get longer.
Do It in Buhata
Reminders and Notes
Set a Buhata Reminder for the same bedtime every night, and note how long the crying lasted in Notes (Premium) so you can see the trend.
Open BuhataRelated Terms and Categories
- Sleep training
Teaching a baby to fall asleep on their own, both at bedtime and after waking in the night, using a planned, consistent method.
- Ferber method
A sleep training method, also called graduated extinction, where parents check on a crying baby at timed intervals that lengthen over time.
- Gentle sleep training
Everyday name for sleep training methods that keep a parent close or step back slowly, such as the chair method or pick up, put down.
- Drowsy but awake
Laying a baby down in the crib when they're sleepy but still awake, so they practice falling asleep on their own.
- Safe sleep
The AAP's rules for lowering the risk of SIDS and suffocation: baby on the back, alone, on a firm flat surface in their own sleep space, every sleep.
- Chair method
A gradual sleep training method where a parent sits in a chair by the crib until the baby falls asleep, moving it farther away every few nights.
Sources
Cleveland Clinic, "What Is the Cry-It-Out Method of Sleep Training?"; Cleveland Clinic, "Sleep Training Your Baby: When and How"; HealthyChildren.org (AAP), "Getting Your Baby to Sleep"; Gradisar and colleagues, "Behavioral Interventions for Infant Sleep Problems: A Randomized Controlled Trial," Pediatrics, 2016; AAP, "Safe Sleep and Your Baby"
- health.clevelandclinic.org/cry-it-out-method
- health.clevelandclinic.org/when-and-how-to-sleep-train-your-baby
- www.healthychildren.org/English/ages-stages/baby/sleep/Pages/getting-your-baby-to-sleep.aspx
- publications.aap.org/pediatrics/article/137/6/e20151486/52401/Behavioral-Interventions-for-Infant-Sleep-Problems
- publications.aap.org/patiented/article/doi/10.1542/peo_document088/79989/Safe-Sleep-and-Your-Baby-How-Parents-Can-Reduce
Last updated .
